UPDATED HOURS: We will be closed Tuesday, July 4 — Saturday, July 8 & open for pickup orders only Friday, July 7 from 10 am — 2 pm

2107 N. Richmond St, Appleton, WI | 920-730-2253

Wednesday – Saturday: 7am – 2pm

2107 N. Richmond St, Appleton, WI | 920-730-2253

Wednesday – Saturday: 7am – 2pm

Hours: Wednesday – Saturday: 7am – 2pm

HOW TO ORDER

custom cakes

We’d love to help make your celebration a little more memorable! If you have a custom cake request for an upcoming wedding or celebration, please ready through the information below.  Once you’re ready to place your order, please give us a call and one of our staff members will be happy to walk you through your order over the phone.

GUIDELINES

In order for our team to have enough time to bake your beautiful cake, we ask that all custom cake orders be submitted 36 hours in advance of your pick up window. We bake Tuesday-Saturday, and cakes can be picked up on those days.

Looking for something sooner than that? Check out our options below!

PRICING

Please be aware that the following prices are starting prices and do not account for any specialty flavor or design up-charges.

FLAVORS

Cake: vanilla, chocolate, marble, blue moon, brownie, lemon, almond, red velvet, carrot, chocolate chip. 
Filling: strawberry, raspberry, cookie dough, blueberry, chocolate ganache, turtle.
Frosting: chocolate, vanilla, lemon, almond, peanut butter, raspberry, blue moon, naturally colored vanilla (your choice of color).

CLICK TO VIEW

custom cakes gallery

COMMON CAKE QUESTIONS

While all of our items at Happy Bellies® Bake Shop are gluten-free, desserts may contain dairy or eggs unless otherwise noted. A full ingredient list is available on request (or you can view the ingredients of some of our main items HERE).

Yes, they are nut free! (unless of course you choose a peanut butter frosting!) We do use nuts in our facility. We note nut allergies and many people do eat here with allergies but can’t guarantee cross contamination as nuts are in our bakery.  

No way! Our custom cakes are made fresh for your event, from scratch, never frozen, and without any preservatives or artificial dyes. We only use natural food coloring! You can learn more about our ingredients here.

We do not use fondant, our cake fillings are all homemade, and we certainly don’t open a pail of frosting for your cake…all frostings are made in house. The frosting is dairy free, too. High five for that!  

Many of our classic flavors are available within the shop case on a daily basis, so feel free to stop in and purchase a few to sample! Otherwise, if there’s a specific flavor you’d like to try or your flavor is not on the current menu, we can set up a custom order.

We offer delivery for custom cakes and large events only. Delivery fees are based on milage and includes driving to and from the location. There is a $30 minimum for all deliveries regardless of location – prices are subject to change with gas price fluctuations. Please be aware that with the exception of a tiered cake, we do not set up at the venue.

Please give us a call at 920-730-2253 to place your order. After receiving your request, someone from the shop will follow up with you to answer any questions you have, provide pricing information, and finalize your order. We look forward to baking for you!

If you need a cake sooner than the 36 hour window, we got you covered! Most of the time cakes are available for purchase in the shop and can have a short custom messaged added if desired (or if we sell out of cakes, we have cupcakes!). Give us a call during our shop hours if you’d like to see what cakes are available before driving over!

Our designs are simple… We add borders and a variety of flowers if desired, along with custom messages and small clip art type designs. Please keep in mind we do use natural coloring, so achieving deep colors is not possible. Black and red are not great options because the colors tend to bleed. Check out the cake gallery below to get an idea of what decorating style we do here.

*Please be aware that any cakes in our photo gallery that have real flowers on them were added after the fact by the event florist (or possibly the client). Let us know if you’d like us to leave space for you to do that!

Please fill out the form or give us a call. We can do specialty flavors upon request and these cakes are available in an 8 or 10 inch size.

Scroll to Top

SAME DAY / NEXT DAY CAKES

If you need a cake sooner than the 36 hour window, we got you covered! Most of the time cakes are available for purchase in the shop and can have a short custom messaged added if desired (or if we sell out of cakes, we have cupcakes!).

Give us a call at 920-730-2253 during our shop hours if you’d like to see what cakes are available before driving over!

VEGAN CAKE PRICING

We offer vegan cakes in addition to our regular, gluten free round cakes. Please see below for pricing information, vegan flavors can be found within the flavors section on our main cake page.

VEGAN CAKE FLAVORS

Cake: vanilla, chocolate, lemon, blue moon, almond, chocolate chip.

Filling: strawberry, raspberry, cookie dough, chocolate ganache.

Frosting: chocolate, vanilla, lemon, almond, peanut butter, raspberry, blue moon, naturally colored vanilla (your color choice).