closed for walk-ins on Tuesdays. place a pre-order by 5pm on Monday and pick up in store Tuesday!

2107 N. Richmond St, Appleton, WI | 920-730-2253

Wednesday – Saturday: 7am – 2pm

2107 N. Richmond St, Appleton, WI | 920-730-2253

Wednesday – Saturday: 7am – 2pm

Hours: Wednesday – Saturday: 7am – 2pm

looking to order ahead?

We’re excited about the opportunity to bake for you! You can place a pre-order online right away if you already know what you’d like, if you want to customize your cake/cupcakes, or if you want a 1/2 dozen or more of the same flavor of one of our staple menu options. If you have special requests, ideas, flavor options, etc, that you don’t see listed, please give us a call and ask!

*If you need just a few dozen items for a special event or wedding, please place a pre-order for your date. More wedding information can be found below.

upcoming wedding or event?

We’d love to help make your celebration or corporate event a little more memorable! If you have a tiered cake request, or if you need to place a large order for over 50 people, please fill out the Special Event Order Form and one of our staff will contact you directly to work with you on your event order. 

For more information about wedding options, cakes, and pricing, please click on the button below after you’ve read through the Common Questions on this page and taken a look at our Photo Gallery. Our most popular flavors and pricing for our special event items are listed on the Special Event PDF below.

Please note bulk orders of less than 4 dozen can be placed through our pre-order option above. Pick your date and submit your request through our online ordering system and we will have it ready for pickup for you on your special day! 

special event order form

Common Questions

Our custom cakes are made fresh for your event, from scratch, never frozen, and without any preservatives or artificial dyes. You can learn more about our ingredients here.

While all of our items at Happy Bellies® Bake Shop are gluten-free, desserts may contain dairy or eggs unless otherwise noted. A full ingredient list is available on request.

We do not use fondant, our cake fillings are all homemade, and we certainly don’t open a pail of frosting for your cake…all frostings are made in house. High five for that!

Many of our flavors are available within the shop case on a daily basis, so feel free to stop in and purchase a few to sample! Otherwise, if there’s a specific flavor you’d like to try or your flavor is not on the current menu, we can set up a custom order.

We offer delivery for custom cakes only. Delivery fees are based on milage at $1.50 per mile and includes driving to and from the location. There is a $30 minimum for all deliveries regardless of location – prices are subject to change with gas price fluctuations. Please be aware that with the exception of a tiered cake, we do not set up at the venue.

We’re looking forward to helping make your special day delicious! Please fill out the Special Request Form below. After receiving your request, someone from the shop will be in contact with you to answer any questions you have, provide pricing information, and finalize your order.

Please be aware that a $50 non-refundable down payment is required with all orders to secure your date. 

photo gallery

Scroll to Top